Below The Beltway

I believe in the free speech that liberals used to believe in, the economic freedom that conservatives used to believe in, and the personal freedom that America used to believe in.

Republicans Have A More Negative View Of Libertarians Than Democrats Or Independents

Interesting results from a Pew Research survey:

More than four-in-ten independents (44%) react positively to the word “libertarian,” while 32% have a negative reaction. Democrats are nearly evenly divided (39% positive, 37% negative). However, Republicans on balance have a negative impression of this term (44% negative, 31% positive).

Bruce McQuain doesn’t find the apparent Republican disdain for libertarians surprising:

In many ways we’re actually competition for Republicans and try to hold them to their principles and slam them when they don’t live up to them. But Republicans don’t like us on the social side of things

Commentators, from the left, of course, draw other conclusions:

The notion that Republicans are libertarian is ludicrous. They stick their noses into our bedrooms, into our doctors’ offices, into churches. They demand the roundup of people who don’t look like them. They whine about Miranda rights and due process. They are more concerned about the rights of big energy conglomerates, than they are about the rights of people to enjoy long walks on pristine beaches. They whine about true independent and free media that doesn’t validate their ideology. They freak out about anyone who doesn’t believe in their god, or worse, in any god at all.

For the American Taliban, “liberty” means their ability to impose their beliefs and lifestyle on the rest of society.

So of course they would react negatively to the word, since they equate it with libertinism. For a movement predicated on imposing its mores on the rest of society, this is obviously deeply offensive.

On some level, I think this is correct, but that certainly doesn’t mean that Democrats or liberals are any more receptive to libertarian ideas than conservative Republicans, or that it’s time to resurrect the absurd idea of a liberal/libertarian fusion.

One Response to “Republicans Have A More Negative View Of Libertarians Than Democrats Or Independents”

  1. Noebie says:

    i am what most people would probably call a “liberal” (though i don’t necessarily accept that label), and although i agree that “fusion” is a bit of a stretch, i also believe that many of the principles of libertarianism are positive, and, indeed, essential to our society

    the tendency toward absolutism is what hinks everything up – it’s one thing to believe that liberty is a right that ought to be unfettered as much as is practically possible – but then there’s that pesky problem of people shouting “fire” in a crowded theater – it’s not unprincipled, in my view, to recognize that there are instances where our personal liberty will (and must) be limited if we’re going to live together in a society that works

    for me, it’s more about balance than it is about any particular set of ideas

    thanks again for a thought-provoking weblog

[Below The Beltway is proudly powered by WordPress.]