Below The Beltway

I believe in the free speech that liberals used to believe in, the economic freedom that conservatives used to believe in, and the personal freedom that America used to believe in.

American Family Association Says Kagan Unqualified If She’s A Lesbian


There have been rumors about Elena Kagan’s personal life ever since her name first surfaced as the front-runner for the Supreme Court, and now the far-right American Family Association is demanding that she answer them:

Speculation continues to swirl about the sexual preference of likely Supreme Court nominee Elena Kagan. She is apparently out to her friends and others in her academic and social circles, but not out to the public at large.

The White House has flatly stated that she is not gay, which could prove a tad embarrassing if the open secret of her lesbianism is confirmed at some point. If she’s a lesbian, it is going to become public knowledge, and the White House will simply have some more egg on its already yoke-splattered face.

Elena Kagan, if nominated today, will be forced to face the press. She cannot be kept closeted not only from the public but from the inquiring minds of the media. They have a solemn responsibility to do one thing: ask her directly and openly and in front of the American people: Are you a lesbian?

A refusal to answer is a tacit admission of guilt. But she may not be able publicly to deny she’s a lesbian, likely because it’s true. She may not be able to admit it either, because it could cost her a Supreme Court post. So she’s likely to refuse to answer the question at all, and the only plausible explanation for her evasion would be because rumors of her lesbianism aren’t rumors at all but based in fact.


One qualification for public office is personal character, and nothing speaks to character more than the choices one makes when it comes to sexual conduct. Bill Clinton convinced an entire generation of America’s youth that oral sex isn’t really sex, and as a result we’ve seen an explosion among millenials in cancers of the throat and head caused by the HPV virus, which is spread through oral-genital contact.

It’s time we got over the myth that what a public servant does in his private life is of no consequence. We cannot afford to have another sexually abnormal individual in a position of important civic responsibility, especially when that individual could become one of nine votes in an out of control oligarchy that constantly usurps constitutional prerogatives to unethically and illegally legislate for 300 million Americans.

The stakes are too high. Social conservatives must rise up as one and say no lesbian is qualified to sit on the Supreme Court. Will they?

Now that you’ve told them their bigotry is a legitimate political issue, they are sure to.

3 Responses to “American Family Association Says Kagan Unqualified If She’s A Lesbian”

  1. Cadam72 says:

    How repugnant. You distill a woman’s entire academic and professional career, without mention of her work for the government, time at Harvard, etc. down to her sexuality. your brand of christian bigotry is disgusting.

  2. Frank N says:

    Oral sex cause cancer?!?!? Too bad stupidity doesn’t.

  3. lahru says:

    these people always want every decision to exclude someone or something to be part of their opinion of what would be the correct decision. I want a Supreme Court that includes everyone and everything.

[Below The Beltway is proudly powered by WordPress.]