Below The Beltway

I believe in the free speech that liberals used to believe in, the economic freedom that conservatives used to believe in, and the personal freedom that America used to believe in.

This Is What Rand Paul Was Really Talking About: Waitress Sues Hooters For “Weight Bias”

Forget the Civil Rights Act of 1964, should this woman have a right to force Hooters to give her a job:

ROSEVILLE, Mich. – A former Hooters waitress who says she was told by management she was too heavy to work has sued the restaurant.
Cassandra Smith says Hooters violated Michigan law when it placed her on 30-day weight probation earlier this month. She resigned as a result.

Smith’s lawsuit, filed Monday in Macomb County Circuit Court, says she received good reviews while working at the Roseville restaurant. But on May 14, she says she was told to lose weight to improve her looks.

Smith says she weighs 132 pounds, 13 pounds less than when she was recruited in 2008.

The lawsuit is apparently based on a Michigan law that prohibits discrimination iscrimination on the basis of religion, marital status, race, age, height and weight. (Which leads me to wonder if a 6′ 1′ 300lb guy could force a local race track to hire him as a jockey, but I digress).

Leave aside the issue of racial and gender discrimination, which have unique historical issues behind them, what possible right does the state have to tell Hooters that it can’t impose a “looks” requirement for it’s waitresses ? It may be crude, it may be classless, but why shouldn’t they have a right to make that decision ?

I for one cannot think of a good reason.

Video:

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

2 Responses to “This Is What Rand Paul Was Really Talking About: Waitress Sues Hooters For “Weight Bias””

  1. chuck says:

    If HOOTERS wants to compare these ladies to The Rockettes then they should be paid accordingly, using entertainment industry standards.

  2. Could this “uniform test” also work in reverse whereby if one of the women lost too much weight and did not fill out her uniform sufficiently that she had to go on a regime of eating to fill out said uniform more fully?

[Below The Beltway is proudly powered by WordPress.]